Why Two Renovation Proposals Can Look So Different

How to Compare Estimates Without Comparing Apples to Oranges

You've met with three renovation companies. Each has visited your home. Each understands that you want to update your kitchen. Now the proposals arrive.

  • One is $28,000.
  • Another is $35,000.
  • The third is $42,000.

Your first reaction?
“How can three companies price the same renovation so differently?”

Here's the important question:
Are they actually proposing the same renovation?

Often, they're not.

The Details Make the Difference

Imagine you're replacing your kitchen cabinets. One proposal includes removing the existing cabinets, installing new cabinetry, replacing countertops, and connecting the sink. Another includes those same items—but also new cabinet hardware, backsplash, undercabinet lighting, drywall repairs, painting, and electrical modifications.

Both proposals say:
Kitchen Renovation.

But the scope is different. And that difference matters.

What's Included—and What's Not?

Before comparing prices, look carefully at what's actually included. Pay particular attention to:

  • Materials: Are the cabinet specifications, countertop materials, flooring products, and fixtures comparable?
  • Preparation: Does the proposal include necessary demolition, floor preparation, wall repairs, and surface preparation?
  • Installation: Are all installation requirements clearly described?
  • Project Management: Who coordinates the trades, scheduling, deliveries, and inspections?
  • Finishing Details: Are painting, trim, cleanup, and final adjustments included?

A lower proposal isn't necessarily missing something. But you need to understand exactly what you're purchasing.

Watch for Allowances and Assumptions

Some proposals include allowances for materials that haven't been selected. For example, a proposal might include a $2,000 countertop allowance. But what happens if the countertop you choose costs $3,500? The difference becomes an additional expense.

Allowances aren't necessarily a problem. Unclear allowances are.
Ask what assumptions were used and how differences will be handled.

Ask About Changes Before They Happen

Renovations occasionally require adjustments. Perhaps hidden water damage is discovered. Maybe you decide to upgrade a fixture. Or an electrical modification becomes necessary. Before signing, understand how those changes will be documented, priced, and approved. You shouldn't have to guess what the final investment will be.

My Perspective

I encourage homeowners to compare renovation proposals line by line, not simply by looking at the number at the bottom. If one company is significantly less expensive, ask why. Maybe they've found a more efficient approach. Perhaps they're using different materials. Or maybe something important isn't included.

A good proposal should help you understand what you're buying, not leave you wondering what's missing.

Coming Next

Once you've selected a renovation company, who makes sure everything happens as planned?

Next week:

Who's Actually Managing Your Renovation?

Excited to transform your home?

Let's bring your vision to life. Get in touch today to begin your design journey.